Farm Insurance Online :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council?w=400
An Australian court recently ruled in favour of the City of Joondalup, rejecting a negligence claim lodged by an injured e-scooter rider.
The Western Australia District Court found the city not liable for an accident involving insurance broker Kirstin Leibbrandt, who collided with a fence post while riding an e-scooter in the Perth suburb of Hillarys.

The court's decision came after Ms Leibbrandt argued that the city had been negligent in situating fence posts too close to the pathway, in defiance of the Austroads Guide to Road Design. Conversely, the city defended its stance, suggesting the incident was a result of Ms Leibbrandt's carelessness while navigating her e-scooter. Judge Alan Troy dismissed her claim, citing that although the risk was foreseeable and not insignificant, it remained minimal for anyone exercising reasonable care.

The accident occurred as Ms Leibbrandt moved to the left to accommodate a cyclist passing from behind, striking a fence post and injuring her wrist. Judge Troy noted her speed of approximately 20-25 km/h on a straight stretch of shared pathway was excessive, contributing to the mishap. The city's defence highlighted that Ms Leibbrandt steered her scooter into the pole during daylight, reiterating that the responsibility lay on the rider's actions.

In its ruling, the court outlined that the Austroads guide, heavily relied upon by Ms Leibbrandt for her case, serves as a general framework rather than a strict mandate. Judge Troy emphasised that road authorities could adapt practices based on local conditions and policies, thus negating negligence claims solely based on deviations from such guidelines.

This verdict underscores the legal principle that local councils are not inherently liable for every accident occurring within public spaces. However, a commentary from law firm Hall & Wilcox advises that authorities should continually evaluate potential hazards, adequately document decisions, and refer to established standards. The judgment endorses a pragmatic approach to public safety, where reasonable measures are expected rather than absolute perfection.

Legal experts suggest this case will likely influence future claims of this nature, potentially shaping how liability is assessed in similar circumstances involving public infrastructure and shared pathways.

Published:Monday, 14th Jul 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council
14 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

An Australian court recently ruled in favour of the City of Joondalup, rejecting a negligence claim lodged by an injured e-scooter rider. The Western Australia District Court found the city not liable for an accident involving insurance broker Kirstin Leibbrandt, who collided with a fence post while riding an e-scooter in the Perth suburb of Hillarys. - read more
Mental Health Surpasses Other Causes in TPD Claims, Doubling Payouts Over Five Years Mental Health Surpasses Other Causes in TPD Claims, Doubling Payouts Over Five Years
14 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

Recent findings from the Council of Australian Life Insurers (CALI) reveal that mental health issues have become the primary cause of Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) claims. Insurers disbursed nearly twice the amount for such claims in 2024 compared to five years prior. This data originates from the CALI and KPMG's Cause of Claims Results Report, highlighting a significant shift in the nature of insurance claims. - read more
Impact of Trump Tariffs on Global Insurance Industry Impact of Trump Tariffs on Global Insurance Industry
11 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

According to Swiss Re’s latest Sigma report, the growth of property and casualty premiums is moderating in both Australia and globally. This moderation is primarily driven by a slowdown in rate hikes. Additionally, the Trump administration's America First trade policy is putting further pressure on the insurance sector. - read more
Navigating Changes in Australia's Life Insurance Advice Landscape Navigating Changes in Australia's Life Insurance Advice Landscape
10 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The conversation on the shifting dynamics in Australia's life insurance advice sector featured Zurich Australia's head of adviser channel, Kieran Forde, and Hayes & Co director, Katherine Hayes. They engaged with editor Chris Dastoor to spotlight the current market conditions and future prospects for financial advisers in this domain. - read more
ASIC Challenges Federal Court's 'Fair Term' Ruling ASIC Challenges Federal Court's 'Fair Term' Ruling
09 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is appealing a Federal Court decision regarding the wording of a 'pre-existing condition' clause in certain HCF Life insurance products. The court previously determined that while the wording had the potential to mislead consumers, it did not constitute an unfair contract term under the current laws set out in the ASIC Act 2001. - read more


Farm Insurance Articles

Comparing Insurance Options for Mixed Farming: What Rural Owners Need to Know Comparing Insurance Options for Mixed Farming: What Rural Owners Need to Know
Welcome to our comprehensive guide on comparing insurance options for mixed farming. As a rural farm owner, you face unique challenges that require specialized insurance coverage to protect your livelihood. - read more
Risk Mitigation: Best Practices for Rural Farmers Risk Mitigation: Best Practices for Rural Farmers
Risk mitigation is a strategy used to prepare for and lessen the effects of potential risks faced by rural farmers. It involves identifying potential threats and taking proactive steps to minimize their impact. - read more
Effective Risk Management Plans Every Farm Owner Should Implement Effective Risk Management Plans Every Farm Owner Should Implement
Managing a farm involves juggling many uncertainties and potential risks. Risk management in farming refers to the process of identifying, assessing, and prioritising risks associated with agricultural activities. Effective risk management ensures that farmers can handle obstacles and continue their operations smoothly. - read more
Preparing for the Unexpected: A Farmer's Guide to Comprehensive Weather-Related Insurance Preparing for the Unexpected: A Farmer's Guide to Comprehensive Weather-Related Insurance
Farmers are no strangers to the whims of nature. The weather, with its unpredictable temperament, can have a profound impact on farming operations. A single storm can lay waste to crops, while a prolonged drought can jeopardize the health of livestock and lead to severe economic strain. Understandably, the uncertainty that weather brings is one of the largest variables in a farmer's success equation. - read more
Understanding Machinery Breakdown Insurance for Australian Farms Understanding Machinery Breakdown Insurance for Australian Farms
Welcome to our in-depth exploration of Machinery Breakdown Insurance—a safety net that's becoming increasingly important for the modern Australian farmer. Whether you're involved in cropping, dairy, or livestock, your equipment is the backbone of your operation. As farming technology evolves, the machinery becomes more sophisticated, and unfortunately, the more complex a system is, the more that can go wrong. This is where Machinery Breakdown Insurance comes into play. - read more
Custom Farm Insurance: Tailoring the Perfect Policy for Your Agricultural Needs Custom Farm Insurance: Tailoring the Perfect Policy for Your Agricultural Needs
Welcome to the world of farm insurance, where no two policies are the same, just as no two farms mirror each other in operations and risks. As a farmer, you are acutely aware that your agricultural endeavors bring a unique set of challenges and needs. Recognizing this diversity is the first step in protecting your livelihood. - read more
Understanding Public Liability Insurance for Livestock and Crop Producers Understanding Public Liability Insurance for Livestock and Crop Producers
Public liability insurance is a critical component for the agricultural sector, serving as a protective measure for livestock and crop producers against the legal liabilities they face in their daily operations. This type of insurance is designed to cover the costs associated with third-party injuries or property damage that occur on farm premises or as a direct result of farming activities. - read more
Safeguarding Your Harvest: The Importance of Crop Insurance Safeguarding Your Harvest: The Importance of Crop Insurance
In the ever-unpredictable world of farming, crop insurance emerges as a pivotal ally for farmers, hedging against the myriad of risks that come with cultivating the land. As the first step to understanding this crucial safeguard, let's unfold the question: What is crop insurance, exactly? In essence, crop insurance is a type of cover designed to cushion farmers from financial losses due to unavoidable circumstances such as adverse weather conditions, pests, disease, or even market fluctuations. - read more
Comparing Insurance Policies: Finding the Best Coverage for Seasonal Farming Risks Comparing Insurance Policies: Finding the Best Coverage for Seasonal Farming Risks
Welcome to our detailed guide on comparing insurance policies for seasonal farming risks. If you're a rural farm owner, you understand the unique challenges that come with each season. This article aims to help you find the best coverage to protect your livelihood. - read more
Essential Coverage: The Top Insurance Policies Every Australian Farmer Should Consider Essential Coverage: The Top Insurance Policies Every Australian Farmer Should Consider
Welcome to a critical discussion surrounding the stability and protection of your farming enterprise. In the unpredictable world of agriculture, insurance plays a pivotal role in safeguarding the future of your business. As we delve into the intricacies of insurance coverage, we aim to establish a strong foundation for enduring success in the farming industry. - read more


Farm Type:
Postcode:

All quotes are provided free (via our secure server) and without obligation. We respect your privacy.

Knowledgebase
Deductible:
The amount you must pay out-of-pocket for expenses before your insurance company covers the remaining costs.